What is the Real Difference Between Various Types of Yeast?

Home 9 Principles of Baking 9 What is the Real Difference Between Various Types of Yeast?

The age-old question – which type of yeast should I use?

The short answer is that you should use the yeast that is available to you at the time, because there is not much difference between all the different kinds of yeast out there.

There are hundreds of yeast species in nature, but only one is used for commercial yeast production – saccharomyces cerevisiae. This strain is extremely good at gas production and it helps your bread puff up.

Commercial yeast comes in different forms from liquid, which is mostly used in large bakeries, cake yeast which we commonly call fresh yeast, and dry yeast.

So, what is the difference between the types of yeast that we find in our shops?

There are three main kinds, to narrow it down – fresh yeast, instant dry yeast, and active dry yeast.

But of course, there are others like easy bake yeast, quick yeast etc. These are basically instant dry yeast, but with a different name.

The main thing to remember is that it is all the same species of yeast, only manufactured differently. The difference is in how you use it.

Instant dry yeast and fresh yeast can be added to flour and mixed in at the same time as all other ingredients.

Active dry yeast on the other hand must be dissolved in water beforehand.

Although I would always recommend dissolving any type of yeast in water before adding flour. This will ensure that there are no lumps, and everything is well dispersed.

There is also a weight difference. Normally the required amount is calculated in relation to fresh yeast. To convert fresh yeast to instant dry yeast you must multiply it by 0.33. To convert fresh yeast to active dry yeast you must multiply it by 0.4.

So, 21g of fresh yeast equals 7g of instant yeast or 8.4g of active dry yeast.

Fresh yeast has a water content of around 70%, so you must keep that in mind when calculating your dough hydration.

But with all the formal stuff out of the way. What is the real-life-bake-at-home difference?

In my experience there is no difference. I normally use instant dry yeast because it is more convenient. It is the most readily available in the local shop, it does not go off in time unlike fresh yeast which you must keep refrigerated, and it just works.

You can use all the different kinds interchangeably. All you need to do is adjust the amount.

Is there a difference in fermentation? As I demonstrate in the video, the fresh yeast did make the dough rise a bit faster. But then you must ask yourself if that is something that you need. I must add that fresh yeast will tolerate salt and sugar a little better, so perhaps the dough rose more quickly because of that.

Is there a difference in flavour in the final loaf? Not to me. Honestly, I did not feel the slightest difference. Maybe someone would, but I think 99% of people would not.

So, why are some people so hung up on a certain kind of yeast? Why do they swear by it? Because it is the yeast that they use, and they have made great bread with it. Or perhaps someone told them to use that yeast. None of which proves that the yeast is amazing.

All you need to know is that yeast does not make bread. You make bread!

My point is that you should not worry too much about the ingredients that you use. You should spend more time learning to use them.

Great bread can be made with any yeast.

 

And please stay away from the blogs and grandma advice. I have read some nonsense in my time. People saying that ‘you should dissolve yeast in water with a teaspoon of sugar and wait for it to bubble up to see of it is still alive’. I mean that is some ridiculous advice right there. If you have any doubt about your yeast being alive or dead, then you should probably buy it somewhere else. You do not go to the shop every day as if it is a lottery. You certainly do not have to do that with any other ingredient, right? I hope not 😊

Speaking of adding sugar to yeast. Click here to see me prove that nonsense wrong too. Sugar is detrimental to yeast activity so you should never add it to yeast to ‘feed it’.

Ok, rant over.

The best thing that you could do is not listen to anyone, or me for that matter, and just try for yourself. Experiment. See what works. And only then go out and tell others about your awesome methods for bread making.

Happy baking!

 

Watch the video down below for a side-by-side comparison.

Watch the video here

Understanding the principles of bread making will let you be in complete control every time you make bread. It will reduce the failure rate and turn you into an even more confident home baker.

I highly recommend you check out the Learning page where I have detailed, easy to understand explanations on each step of the bread baking process and the principles behind it. You can find all the equipment I use and recommend in the Shop (UK) & Shop (US) pages.

Show/Hide Comments (2 comments)
L

2 Comments

  1. Ray

    About grandma’s advice to “prove the yeast in lukewarm water with a bit of sugar, and wait for bubbles” — it is very useful for home bakers who don’t bake often. Some of us will have a batch of yeast sitting in our fridge for months or years, and we’re not sure if its still alive. Hence that proving step is useful, and saves us from the frustration of a non-rising dough because of dead yeast. (Yeast is fungi btw, not bacteria,. Pardon the biologist in me speaking — calling those types of yeast “the same microorganism” will have been more accurate).

    Because of the pandemic, I was forced to use fresh yeast as it was the only one available. I loved using it, the smell of dough while fermenting is sweeter, and the dough structure have finer bubbles. Besides, I also found out that it’s possible to freeze fresh yeast. Crumble the yeast cake in flour, then wrap small balls of the mixture in plastic wrap, with each portion enough for a single bake. This frozen fresh yeast last for a year, but I finished mine in less than 6 months.

    Reply
    • ChainBaker

      Hi Ray. That’s a fair point. If the yeast has been sitting for so long, then it would be a good way of checking. But most of the time people don’t use this method for that purpose.
      Yeah about the ‘bacteria’, I did have microorganism in my mind as I was narrating but the confused foreigner came out and said the wrong word 😄
      That’s a great way of working around the short shelf life. Thanks for sharing! 👍

      Reply

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

More Posts

How to Autolyse Enriched Dough

How to Autolyse Enriched Dough

Autolysis with fat. I have had several people ask me about this. So, here we are. Another experiment to see why we should or should not do it. Gluten is made up of two proteins, glutenin and...

read more